Response to “Why I’ve Stopped Singing in Your Church”

The article to which I am responding can be found here: http://www.patheos.com/blogs/faithwalkers/2012/07/why-ive-stopped-singing-in-your-church/

A friend at church asked me to respond to this article, and I thought it would be good to post my response to him publicly. I am interested in your thoughts, both on Bill’s article and on my response!

The author’s issues are that modern worship songs are simple and repetitive, and that many worship leaders prefer using modern worship songs (and/or modern instrumentation). His patronizing language is unnecessary and hurts his cause—maybe he’s just trying to lighten the mood?—but I agree with his points.

These points, while true, are pretty vaporous to me. Of course modern worship leaders are going to prefer modern songs, and of course they’re going to take old lyrics/melodies and set them to modern music. Why wouldn’t they? They’re modern people. Regarding “truth-less” songs and those “written for children,” I’d say that while some songs are distractingly simple and repetitive, many are not. The recent explosion of Christian worship music is a blessing, not a curse, and his exaggeration injures his credibility.
To the issue of not using enough hymns, it sounds like he has an authority problem… either that or he’s making an incredible assumption about every church. If the latter, he’s just wrong. If the former, he should go to his church’s pastors/elders and ask what they think about the current song selections and work through their answer.
Regarding changing chords and tempo to make sense to the modern ear, I believe Luther, Wesley, and many others would roll over in their grave if they knew there existed a group of believers who pushed for hymns to be cryogenically frozen in the 19th/20th century—especially if those believers referred to that petrification as “timelessness.” (Usually people think the “right” way to do something is the way they grew up doing it… when related to church issues, I’ve heard it called “baptizing your preferences”).
Two responses outside of his particular points:
1. Corporate worship shouldn’t be a person’s primary outlet for Christian singing. I already assume it’s not their only outlet. He’d probably agree with this, but it seems like he has a lot—a LOT—riding on those 5 or 6 songs on a Sunday morning. If every person in his congregation expected to get what they wanted out of every service, then no service, pastor, or church could ever match up. Not in a 10-person church, and certainly not with a few hundred people.
2. Worship (and I don’t mean “music”) isn’t about what a person gets out of it; it’s what they put into it. He might argue he can’t put anything into it because he can’t sing, but that’s silly. I would tell him about a time I visited a Vietnamese church, and although I couldn’t read the words or understand what they were saying as they sang, just listening to the others was an act of deep, deep worship for me. One of the deepest in my life.
I would hope that Bill’s private singing and maturity in Christ would let his corporate worship times be similarly sublime. And I would hope that his church’s worship leader would draw from the rich bank of songs from today and from ages past.

Nativity EP is out!

Hi all, I’m so glad to announce that a few weeks ago I released Nativity, my first album as a lead singer. I’d love to hear that you’ve been singing along with these Nativity EP album coverChristmas carol arrangements, and I hope they even find their way into your church’s services. Huge thanks to Justin Wright for producing it, Mark Suhonen for mastering it, Evan Amo for playing bass, and Jamie Keller for singing lead on Oh Come All Ye Faithful. It is truly an album by friends, for friends.

Search for Nativity on iTunes, Google Play, or any other major music site.

#nativityone

Tagged

Worship setlist 11.16.14

*Paige led this weekend, and I was on bass. I had way too much fun.

Your Love Never Fails

One Thing Remains

Oceans (Where Feet May Fail)

Cannons

He Is Faithful

Tagged

Worship setlist 11.9.14

Open the Eyes of My Heart – I unpacked Ephesians 1:18 briefly in the middle of the song. Essentially, God opening the eyes of our heart is not a request for more data–more information about God so that we can collate, assimilate, and aggregate. It’s saying “God, flood my heart with light. Flood it with love. Flood it with you.”

Never Once

Our God

Revelation Song

Beautiful One

Tagged

Worship setlist 11.2.14

Glory to God Forever

Mighty to Save

Open the Eyes of My Heart (V, C, C)

10,000 Reasons

Beautiful Things

Here For You

Tagged

Worship setlist 10.26.14

This is Amazing Grace

God is Able

From the Inside Out

Holy, Holy, Holy

Forever Reign

Tagged

Worship setlist 10.19.14

Everlasting God

Beneath the Waters

Special Music: Oh God

All Creatures of Our God and King

Christ is Enough

It is Well (C, V3, C, C)

Tagged

Worship setlist 10.12.14

Nothing But the Blood

Jesus Lord of Heaven

In Christ Alone

Be Lifted High

This I Believe

Not to Us

Tagged

Worship setlist 10.5.14

Rejoice

Divine Romance

Cornerstone

Be Thou My Vision

Awakening

Whom Shall I Fear

Tagged

Worship setlist 9.28.14

Our God

How He Loves

Come Thou Fount

Revelation Song

It is Finished (Kensrue)

Tagged
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 53 other followers